Overview Students learn about a selection of religious celebrations, such as Eid, Diwali and Hanukkah. Using resources about world celebrations from the Internet and textbooks from the library, they focus on visible practices and customs, identifying similarities and differences with common celebrations in Australia (e.g. Christmas and Easter). Explanation For many schools, this approach is a starting point and can provide students with greater cultural awareness. But it cannot be the end goal. On its own, it is unlikely to foster higher-order intercultural understanding, skills, behaviours and dispositions.
The approach runs the risk of promoting superficial awareness of a selection of cultures. It also has the capacity to reinforce ethnocentric and generalised views of ‘cultures’, seeing these as discrete and static, as opposed to dynamic and changing. This is because teaching and learning has not been constructed to promote critical thinking about cross-cultural interaction, self-reflexivity, perspective taking, empathy and action. Relying on generic resources could mean that authentic and culturally diverse sources are not an intentional aspect of teaching and learning for the topic. | » | Overview Students learn about a selection of religious celebrations, such as Eid, Diwali and Hanukkah. They use authentic materials, i.e. culture-specific books written by people of that particular culture, to explore visible practices and customs. They identify similarities and differences with common celebrations in Australia (e.g. Christmas and Easter). A small group of parents from Muslim, Hindu and Jewish backgrounds are invited to the school to share their experiences with students. Students visit the Islamic Museum of Australia, a Hindu temple or the Jewish Museum to gain a deeper insight into one cultural perspective and its celebrations. Explanation
The use of authentic perspectives and perspectives can provide students with deeper cultural insights, which builds on the Contributions approach. However, teaching and learning has not been modified sufficiently to enable transformative thinking and behaviour with respect to cultural diversity. Furthermore, the approach can still promote the idea that cultures are discrete and unchanging, instead of dynamic. It potentially reinforces ethnocentricity and essentialist views of culture, rather than foster genuine intercultural understanding. | » | Overview Students explore the theme of ‘celebrations’ as an inquiry topic. They investigate celebrations as an age-old social phenomenon and consider the significance of celebrations and its different types. Using a range of religious/cultural celebrations as examples, e.g. Eid, Diwali, Hanukkah, Christmas and Easter, students seek to understand why people come together to celebrate and how different celebrations are connected. Students use authentic materials, i.e. culture-specific books written by people of that particular culture, to explore visible practices and customs. A small group of parents from Muslim, Hindu and Jewish backgrounds are invited to the school to share their experiences. Students visit the Islamic Museum of Australia, a Hindu temple or the Jewish Museum to gain a deeper insight into one cultural perspective and its celebrations. Explanation The theme of ‘celebrations’ is viewed from several cultural perspectives so students can understand the complex ways in which diverse groups interact and participate in the formation of society. It enables diverse cultural perspectives to be included in teaching and learning as a matter of course, empowering students from minority cultural backgrounds in the process. It promotes perspective taking, reflexivity, interactivity and empathy building. In this example, the structure of teaching and learning has been modified substantially to transform students’ thinking and behaviour with respect to cultural diversity. The Transformation approach is further reinforced by the use of authentic resources that showcase a range of voices. This helps facilitate cross-cultural dialogue and conversations so students can explore other worldviews whilst reflecting on their own background and identities. The intended outcome is a student who understands there are many ways of seeing the world, who possesses the skills, behaviours and dispositions to navigate the implications of intercultural relations, and who understands why people do what they do. |